Plus, Fog stymies Waymo's robo-taxis.

View in Browser

Reuters Auto File
Reuters Auto File

Greetings from the Motor City!

 

Today’s Auto File is largely devoted to breaking down the Biden Administration’s just-released plan to speed the U.S. auto industry toward its most profound transformation in over a century. To paraphrase President Joe Biden, the Environmental Protection Agency’s proposals to use pollution standards to push EVs to a 67% share of the U.S. market by 2032 are a big %^$@! deal.

 

And yes, there are other stories from the World of Cars:

  • Washington wants to mandate a big shift to EVs
  • Hyundai’s $18 billion promise to South Korea
  • Fog flummoxes self-driving Waymo cars

Endangered species?

Uncle Sam wants you to drive an EV

The Biden Administration on Wednesday officially unveiled its proposal to ratchet down the carbon dioxide pumped out by petrol-burning cars and trucks through 2032 and boost electric vehicles towards a two-thirds share of the U.S. new vehicle market by 2032.

 

The text of the EPA proposal is here. In this case, believe the hype: If this proposal is adopted, the changes in the U.S. auto sector – from factory floor to showroom – will be profound.

 

The rule is part of what my Reuters colleague David Shepardson describes as a three-way squeeze on internal combustion engines.

 

The EPA’s proposed vehicle CO2 standards for 2027-2032 are part one. The EPA proposal doesn’t require specific technology. But the proposal’s overall target of reducing CO2 emissions from new vehicles 56% by 2032 amounts to a requirement for the industry to sell a lot more electric vehicles.

 

The administration plan foresees the electric vehicle share of the U.S. new light vehicle market rising to 67% by 2032 from 7% last year.

 

The 67% EV share goal is also well north of the 50% target the Biden Administration set in 2021. The difference between 50% and 67% market share translates to roughly 2.5 million vehicles in the U.S. market – or about eight factories worth of cars and trucks.

 

The emissions rules are a stick laid on automakers. The hundreds of billions of dollars in incentives for consumers and businesses to buy EVs (and automakers to produce them) that are provided by the Inflation Reduction Act are designed to be a carrot.

 

The EPA’s view is that economics and consumer choice will drive the surge in EV sales. By 2032, new EVs could cost $1,200 more to buy than a comparable combustion vehicle, but owners would save $9,000 to $13,000 in operating costs over the vehicle’s life, the EPA estimates.

 

The auto industry has numerous concerns, outlined Wednesday by John Bozzella, head of the Alliance for Automotive Innovation:

  • Will EV charging infrastructure be adequate to support the administration’s goals?
  • Will consumer interest in EVs grow if federal purchase subsidies are being cut?
  • Why isn’t the EPA acting to reduce the carbon intensity of liquid fuels (in other words, put pressure on Big Oil, too.)
  • Why is the industry still confronting multiple state and federal tailpipe pollution regulations?

 

The proposal worries some climate action advocates, too. In theory, a Detroit automaker could keep selling petrol-fueled pickup trucks without making significant reductions in their pollution output. The company would just sell fewer of them, alongside a larger fleet of EVs to balance out the average.

 

“The draft rule fails to require any improvement in the tens of millions of new gas guzzlers, and even the strongest option falls well short of the 75% pollution cut necessary to protect our planet,” Dan Becker of the Safe Climate Transport Campaign wrote Wednesday.

 

Part two is a proposal by the Department of Energy to sharply reduce the Miles Per Gallon equivalent, or MPGe, ratings for EVs. That would give automakers less credit under the government’s emissions scorekeeping systems for EVs they sell, effectively compelling them to deliver more EVs to offset big, fossil-fuel burning trucks and SUVs. Breakingviews has an analysis of the impact of this shift.

 

Third, the Biden administration is ramping up the fines it levies on companies that miss federal CO2/fuel economy targets.

 

To sum it up:

 

The administration pro-EV moves are important both as industrial policy and political strategy, and they present risks in both dimensions.

 

First the political challenges. Voters concerned about climate change – many of them Democrats – want the administration to get tougher on the transport sector – the largest source of greenhouse gas emissions. Going too easy on the automakers risks a backlash from a core constituency.

 

At the same time, many voters are concerned that EV technology and infrastructure don’t meet their needs. Republicans, such as House Speaker Kevin McCarthy, started bashing the EPA proposal went public. One line of attack is that shifting to EVs gives more power to China, which dominates EV battery production and materials.

 

As industrial policy, the administration is making a bet that EV demand in the U.S. vehicle market will leap nearly ten-fold from current levels by 2032.

 

Forecasts on future U.S. EV demand vary. Moody’s this week reckoned EV market share will rise to 35% to 40% in the United States by 2030 and could hit 55-60% by 2035.

 

“Risks for this carbon transition are high, if not very high, for the industry, because electrification will require further substantial investments into new BEVs, battery technology, supply chain and manufacturing capacity, and charging infrastructure,” wrote Matthias Heck, Moody's Vice President and Senior Credit Officer.

 

The impact on jobs will be a central question. The United Auto Workers is concerned a rapid shift to EVs will put thousands of jobs at risk. Beryllis, a consultancy, estimates a third of combustion vehicle capacity could become redundant by 2030.

 

UAW members are a key constituency in Michigan and other Midwest election year swing states.

 

And what if EV sales fall short? Automakers could be pushed into profit-destroying price wars to duck fines – and avoid writing off billions invested in EV factories and vehicles. Another down-side risk is that drivers could hang on to aging combustion vehicles even longer than they do now.

 

A final wild card could be the outcome of future Presidential elections. When the White House changed hands in 2017, automakers appealed to the new Republican administration to roll back emissions rules agreed with the prior Democratic White House.

 

What will happen? Maybe Arnold Schwarzenegger will travel back from the future in an electric BMW to tell us.

 

 

Essential Reading

  • What is a “double SPAC?”
  • Elon Musk says Twitter is breaking even
  • The IMF’s gloomy economic outlook
 

A Hyundai Kona EV.

Hyundai promises South Korea $18 billion  

Hyundai committed to investing the equivalent of $18 billion to develop electric vehicle production in its home country. Hyundai’s announcement coincided with a visit by South Korean President Yoon Suk Yeol to the groundbreaking for Hyundai Group brand Kia’s first all-EV factory.

 

Hyundai, like other national champion automakers, is juggling the lure of U.S. EV manufacturing subsidies – and build-them-here policies in other markets – with the need to stay strong in its own backyard.

 

A Zeekr O01 EV in Shanghai.

Geely’s Zeekr brand takes on Tesla  

Zeekr, one of the EV brands launched by China’s Geely, used the runup to the Shanghai Auto show to unveil a new electric SUV with an on-board refrigerator and other luxury amenities aimed at Tesla’s Model Y and new electric SUVs from German premium brands.

 

What’s not so premium is the price: Under $28,000 in U.S. dollars. Why is Tesla cutting prices? This is why.

 

Waymo robotaxis get fogged in

San Francisco’s famous fog has provided a comical reminder of the challenges facing the autonomous vehicle industry. Waymo said some of its automated robo-taxis pulled over to the side of the road after dense fog blinded the sensors. Last week, rival robo-taxi operator Cruise recalled and updated 300 of its San Francisco self-driving vehicles after one of them hit a bus.

 

Fast Laps

Auto industry veteran Johan de Nysschen will become CEO of Propitious Technologies, a startup that has developed technology that uses the energy generated by a semi-trailer’s suspension to power the trailer’s refrigeration system. The diesel generators currently used on on reefer trailers can emit up to 22.5 pounds of CO2 per gallon burned, and do not have to meet the other pollution standards for truck engines.

 

CarMax surprised investors with better than expected profits, driven by cost-cutting and stricter discipline in buying used cars. Still, revenue was down, a symptom of tighter credit and higher prices keeping many would-be buyers stuck in their old rides.

 

Ford will retool a combustion SUV factory in Oakville, Ontario, starting next year, to build a new generation of electric SUVs. Ford had promised the C$1.8 billion investment during 2020 contract talks with Unifor, the Canadian industrial union.

 

GM is investing in a lithium startup, EnergyX, that is working to scale up a process to extract the battery mineral directly from brine. Direct lithium extraction, or DLE, has so far not been developed at commercial scale. GM’s participation in the $50 million funding round is just one of the automaker’s direct investments in battery mineral mining and refining.

 

Electric van startup Arrival is executing rapid maneuvers to shore up its shaky capital structure. The company said it would undergo a second SPAC acquisition – this time merging with  Kensington Capital Acquisition Corp V (KCGI.N). Then, Arrival  said it will launch a reverse stock split, consolidating 50 shares of stock into one.

 

Waymo and Aurora face opposition from a U.S. transport workers union in their effort to persuade U.S. regulators to waive certain rules that effectively require a human being to be aboard a Class 8 truck.

 

We think you may like this:

 

Reuters Sustainable Switch

Make sense of companies and governments grappling with climate change, diversity, and human rights. 

Subscribe
 

Sponsors are not involved in the creation of newsletters or other Reuters news content.

 

Auto File is sent three days a week. Think your friend or colleague should know about us? Forward this newsletter to them. They can also sign up here.

 

Want to stop receiving this newsletter? Unsubscribe here.
To manage which newsletters you're signed up for, click here.

 

Follow Reuters on social media

FacebookTwitterInstagram
 

Reuters Terms & Conditions and Privacy Statement

© 2023 Thomson Reuters. All rights reserved.

3 Times Square, New York, NY 10036