Good morning. Sarah Palin’s defamation trial against the New York Times is set to begin in Manhattan federal court, and legal scholars offer insight into what’s at stake. Plus, the federal judiciary is weighing a proposal to raise the bar on expert witness testimony, Michael Avenatti heads to trial to face fraud charges, and Mayer Brown’s opening its 27th office. It’s Monday, and we’re buckled in for a big week. Let’s get started.
Were you forwarded this email? Subscribe here.
Lawyers for former Alaska Republican governor Sarah Palin and for the New York Times are set to appear today in Manhattan federal court for a rare trial involving a major media company defending its editorial practices before a jury. Palin’s lawsuit accused the Times of defaming her in a 2017 editorial that she said falsely linked her to a mass shooting that seriously wounded then-U.S. Representative Gabby Giffords.
Palin’s lawyers shoulder a high burden of showing "actual malice" was involved in the newspaper's editorial writing process, our colleagues Jonathan Stempel and Helen Coster write in a Reuters analysis of the case. "This is a lawsuit over an editorial, essentially an opinion. This is a potentially dangerous area," Roy Gutterman, a Syracuse University law and communications professor, told Reuters.
Kenneth Turkel and Shane Vogt of the Tampa litigation boutique Bajo Cuva Cohen Turkel are on the team for Palin with attorneys Michael Munoz and S. Preston Ricardo of the New York firm Golenbock Eiseman Assor Bell & Peskoe. Turkel and Vogt were lawyers for the former wrestler Hulk Hogan in his privacy lawsuit against Gawker over its online publication of a sex tape. Hogan settled his claims for $31 million in 2016.
Ballard Spahr partners David Axelrod, Jay Brown and Thomas Sullivan are defending the Times. Brown has been a leading media and entertainment lawyer for decades. He was a co-founder in 1997 of the First Amendment boutique Levine Sullivan Koch & Schulz. The firm merged with Ballard Spahr in 2017. Axelrod leads the firm's securities enforcement and corporate governance litigation group.
Read what legal experts are saying about Palin’s case.
Corporate defense attorneys are pushing the federal judiciary to raise the bar on expert witnesses and make it harder for what they say is junk science to get into courtrooms.
The judiciary’s Advisory Committee on Evidence Rules held a hearing on whether to amend an evidentiary rule to say that a party must prove by a preponderance of evidence that expert testimony is admissible — a new requirement.
Defense lawyers and groups on the defense side are backing the proposal, our colleague Nate Raymond reports, while the plaintiffs bar has argued that the change could lead to judges improperly evaluating whether expert witnesses are correct ahead of trial.
Read more about the potential change and what it could mean for product liability cases.
- Mayer Brown is opening a new office in Salt Lake City, becoming the latest major U.S. firm to set up in the technology-heavy region. The team of lawyers in the firm’s 27th office will include Jennifer Carlson, a capital markets partner who will relocate from the firm's San Francisco and Palo Alto offices. She'll be joined by three former Stoel Rives partners. (Reuters)
- A group of health insurers represented by Sheppard Mullin wants a federal appeals court to strike down a nearly $185 million attorneys’ fee award to Quinn Emanuel for its work securing $3.7 billion for a class of health plans that sought payments under an Obamacare program. Quinn will get a chance soon in the Federal Circuit to defend the fee, which the objecting insurance companies called “astronomical.” (Reuters)
- A former shareholder at Vedder Price who admitted to cheating his clients out of nearly $80,000 by generating fake invoices and reimbursement requests will be suspended from the bar for three years. Robert Hankes worked at Vedder Price focusing on aircraft financing from 2005 until his dismissal in 2019. (Reuters)
- Students at the University of Virginia School of Law are taking a new class on the hit HBO show “Succession,” which uses plot points to teach elements of corporate law. (Reuters)
- A Pennsylvania federal judge criticized lawyers at small New York real estate firm Harras Bloom & Archer for “sloppiness” in their patent case against UCLA. The reprimand from U.S. District Judge Joshua Wolson suggested “more experienced” patent counsel should have been consulted. (Reuters)
- Kirkland and Clifford Chance are counseling European lottery operator Allwyn Entertainment as it goes public through a merger with a former Trump advisor-backed blank check firm represented by Skadden. (Reuters)
That’s about how many government workers are impacted by a ruling from U.S. District Judge Jeffrey Brown in Galveston, Texas, that blocked the Biden administration’s requirement that all federal employees be vaccinated against COVID-19. The law firm Boyden Gray & Associates represented plaintiffs Feds for Medical Freedom. The Justice Department said it will appeal. Read more about the ruling.
Reuters video journalist Alex Cohen gives you an early view of the week ahead in legal news. Watch the video. And to hear what’s coming up this week, listen to Tom Rowe’s Audio Lookahead.
"[I]t is not unreasonable, moving forward, for plaintiffs to believe that UF will use its policy to squelch their speech; it is unreasonable for them to believe that it will not."
—Chief U.S. District Judge Mark Walker, who ruled for a group of law professors at the University of Florida who accused the school of unconstitutionally barring them from acting as expert witnesses or signing on to amicus briefs in cases that are critical of state policies. The professors asked for a preliminary injunction barring the school from implementing the policy, and Walker granted it with respect to serving as expert witnesses or legal consultants. Read the judge's order here.
- Onetime celebrity lawyer Michael Avenatti will go on trial in Manhattan federal court on charges he defrauded former client Stormy Daniels, the adult film star who alleged an affair with Donald Trump. Federal prosecutors in Manhattan say Avenatti embezzled $300,000 in book contract proceeds intended for Daniels. Avenatti has pleaded not guilty. The proceeding will mark the third criminal trial of the longtime attorney who rose to prominence as a critic of Trump.
- Texas faces a deadline to respond to a request last week from abortion clinics to fast track litigation in the Texas Supreme Court over the new state law that is a near total ban on abortion. The 5th Circuit sent the case to the state court to review an enforcement question, delaying litigation in a federal court in a legal challenge to the law. Marc Hearron, a lead lawyer for the clinics that sued over the law, said the Texas court should consider ruling on earlier-filed briefs and skipping oral argument as a means to expedite its review.
- Stewart Rhodes, founder of the far-right Oath Keepers, will appear in Texas federal court for a detention hearing in the government’s seditious conspiracy case tied to the Jan. 6, 2021, deadly attack on the U.S. Capitol. Federal prosecutors will argue for detention pending trial. “He is a graduate of Yale Law School and has previously served in the military. Those experiences highlight that [Elmer] Rhodes should have and did know better; they support that his words were deliberate, that his deeds were calculated, and that his intent was criminal,” prosecutors said in a court filing. U.S. Magistrate Judge Kimberly Priest Johnson in Plano will preside.
- An Arizona judge is expected to rule on whether to dismiss a lawsuit brought by state Attorney General Mark Brnovich accusing Google of misleading users with unclear smartphone location tracking settings. Brnovich worked with private firms Cooper & Kirk and Ruttenberg IP Law on the complaint in Maricopa County Superior Court. Perkins Coie partner Jean-Jacques Cabou is on the team for Google.
Court calendars are subject to last-minute docket changes.
- The 4th Circuit on Tuesday is scheduled to hear oral arguments over the fate of a lawsuit by the city of Baltimore seeking monetary damages from BP PLC and other energy companies due to costs caused by climate change. The arguments will revolve around the technical issue of whether the case belongs in federal court or state court. Baltimore and a handful of plaintiffs in similar lawsuits are fighting to keep the litigation in plaintiff-friendly state courts. Paul Weiss partner Kannon Shanmugam will argue for the oil companies, and Victor Sher of Sher Edling will argue for Baltimore.
- On Thursday, the 4th Circuit will consider whether to overturn an injunction barring South Carolina from enforcing a ban on almost all abortions in the state. The women's health group Planned Parenthood sued soon after South Carolina Governor Henry McMaster, a Republican, in February signed into law a so-called "fetal heartbeat" law that banned abortion after a fetal heartbeat is detected, often at six weeks and before a woman realizes she is pregnant.
- A Kansas City federal judge on Friday will hear H&R Block's bid for a preliminary injunction to halt Block's use of its new name, based on its arguments that the company formerly known as Square will cause confusion with the tax-services giant. Block, represented by Quinn Emanuel, has argued that it doesn't offer any customer-facing products under the name, and that a reasonable consumer couldn't confuse its competing tax-preparation product with H&R Block's services. A team from Debevoise represents H&R Block.
Court calendars are subject to last-minute docket changes.
- The U.S. Supreme Court will consider limiting the scope of its own 2020 ruling that expanded Native American tribal authority in Oklahoma in a case involving a man convicted of child neglect. Kannon Shanmugam of Paul Weiss represents Oklahoma, and Zachary Schauf of Jenner is leading the team for a man named Victor Castro-Huerta. (Reuters)
- The 1st Circuit upheld a lower court judge's decision to dismiss a whistleblower lawsuit accusing manufacturers of multiple sclerosis drugs and pharmacy benefit managers of colluding to defraud Medicare. The U.S. Justice Department had argued for the dismissal of the lawsuit. (Reuters)
- Alaska Governor Michael Dunleavy, a Republican, and his chief of staff unlawfully fired a state lawyer, Elizabeth Bakalar, after she harshly criticized former President Donald Trump on her personal blog, a federal judge said. Bakalar, who called Trump a "treasonous, semi-literate, lecherous oligarch," had her free-speech rights violated by the firing, U.S. District Judge John Sedwick said in his ruling. (Reuters)
- Google asked a New York federal judge to dismiss the majority of an antitrust lawsuit filed by Texas and other states that accused the search giant of abusing its dominance of the online advertising market. Lawyers from the firms Freshfields, Wilson Sonsini and Axinn Veltrop represent Google. (Reuters)
- Goodwin said debt finance partner Robby Stein has joined the firm’s private equity team in New York. Stein arrives at the law firm from Akerman, where he was co-chair of the corporate finance and lending practice. (Goodwin)
- Bryan Cave hired finance transaction lawyer Braden Shaw as a partner in the firm’s Chicago office. Shaw joins the firm from Vedder Price. (Bryan Cave)
- Quarles & Brady has added Janet Lindeman to the firm's real estate practice in its Chicago office. Previously, Lindeman was an assistant general counsel for Ulta, where she handled real estate matters. (Quarles & Brady)
- Clark Hill added Alex Pérez as a tax services member in the firm’s San Antonio and Mexico City offices. He joins from Sañudo Pérez, which he co-founded and co-owned. (Clark Hill)
- Pierre Yanney jumped to Wiggin and Dana from Bressler, Amery & Ross. He’ll be a partner in Wiggin's intellectual property practice group and chair of the patent prosecution group. (Wiggin and Dana)
Copyright © 2022 Thomson Reuters. All rights reserved. 610 Opperman Drive, Eagan, MN 55123
Want to change how you receive these emails? You can unsubscribe from this list here.
|